Topic: Health (235)

First Murray. Now Larsen. Half Trillion Dollar Theft From Medicare: Not An Issue.

Heaven forbid our reps should attack the main problem, Medicare Advantage, head on. But no. They must nibble around the edges to give the appearance of doing something.

Heaven forbid our reps should attack the main problem, Medicare Advantage, head on. But no. They must nibble around the edges to give the appearance of doing something.

By
• Topics: Health, Health, Health,

About a month ago,  I wrote an article about a response I got from our Senator, Patty Murray, in which she totally ignored the crux of my communication with her regarding the Medicare Advantage (MA) grand theft of over a half trillion dollars from the Medicare Trust Fund. Rick Larsen replied to me with a similarly clueless missive when I wrote to him to point out the same issue, grand theft from the American elderly. 

Here is the text [italicized] of Larsen's response with my comments in red text:

"Thank you for contacting me about Medicare Advantage. It is critical to my work to hear from you and I welcome the opportunity to write to you.*

"I support Medicare and ensuring people can receive the quality, affordable health care to which they are entitled. In Washington state, almost 1.5 million people are enrolled in Medicare, and 45% of those beneficiaries have a Medicare Advantage plan. Selecting a health care plan is a personal decision based on an individual’s medical and financial situation, and it is essential that Congress improve all Medicare options available to enrollees. 

Sorry Rep Larsen, we are not talking about personal decisions here regarding health care. We are talking about a SYSTEM that promotes Medicare Advantage, that pushes it in the faces of seniors on Medicare and then gives billions upon billions of dollars to the private sector to the detriment of all Medicare insured. Personal health decisions, that you tout as a hallmark of medical and financial situations, are taken from the patients and their doctors and put in the hands of insurance lackeys and financial managers. The only possible improvement is the repeal of legislation that created MA and the placement of all MA insureds back into Traditional Medicare.

"That is why I joined colleagues in a letter urging the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to increase transparency in Medicare Advantage plans and require a deadline for those plans to respond to requests for urgently needed care. I also support the Improving Seniors Timely Access to Care Act, legislation to streamline Medicare Advantage’s prior authorization process.

Again, it ain't about streamlining anything, as you suggest with the Improving Seniors Timely Access to Care Act. It is about getting rid of Medicare Advantage in its entirety so that the program can no longer steal from the Medicare Trust Fund. If Traditional Medicare were simply expanded (using the dollars now stolen by Medicare Advantage), there would be no prior authorization to deal with, no streamlining necessary. The continuing lie perpetrated by Medicare Advantage proponents is that these insurers add “value” and stop waste. The truth is exactly the opposite. The watchdogs, risibly called “case managers” within some MA insurance companies, work to deny care, delay care, cut payments to providers and generally muck about with the system that serves some of the most vulnerable in our society.  

"Congress must also be vigilant against waste, fraud and abuse, while preventing reductions to essential health benefits or increasing beneficiaries' share of costs. That is why I joined my colleagues in opposing pending Medicare reimbursement cuts, which will reduce access to health care. I also support legislation to lower Medicare eligibility to age 60 and expand coverage to include eye exams and glasses, hearing aids and dental care. 

Yes. Just by eliminating MA we could pay for the eye exams, glasses, hearing aids, and dental care. And why lower eligibility to just age 60? Establish Medicare for All and rid our country of the insurance vultures who treat people's health care as if it were carrion.  Presently, the taxpayers' 1.45% Medicare portion of the FICA (Federal Insurance Contributions Act) hospital insurance tax is applied to the first $200K annual earnings for single filers and $250K for joint filers. After that, the percentage drops to 0.9%. This needs to change so that the 1.45% is applied to ALL earnings--no cap. The Medicare Trust Fund will recover our current losses and become sustainable, and the regressive nature of the FICA tax will be eliminated.

"In addition, my offices in Everett and Bellingham are always available to assist you, should you experience any difficulties with your personal Medicare benefits. 

“Thank you again for contacting me. I appreciate hearing from you, and I am listening. Please continue to reach out.”

 

That being said, I will give Larsen credit for having paid attention to my earlier missive to him in April, 2022 regarding another, more insidious form of grand theft from Medicare, that is, Direct Contracting Entities (DCE), also known now as ACO Reach. In his response [see the full letter at FILES below] to me he wrote:  

"I oppose Medicare privatization and am concerned DCEs could weaken health coverage for many traditional Medicare patients.  

"DCEs are part of a model run by the Center for Medicare and Medicaid Innovation (CMMI). CMMI runs these models to test efficiencies in the Medicare system. However, I have heard from dozens of constituents with concerns that the DCE model might impact their quality of care and choice in medical coverage.  

“In response, I wrote directly to Administrator for the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, which oversees CMMI, to answer the concerns I am hearing from Northwest Washington. Please know I will keep monitoring this situation and working to strengthen Medicare.”

 

Interestingly though, he does not seem to equate MA with privatization such as with the DCEs. I think Larsen, like many in Congress, just does not understand these programs even after years or decades in elective office.

 

*Obligatory politeness before a response that ignores the essence of my message to him. But as with Sen Murray's website, there is no copy of one's message sent through the website to the member of congress that comes back to the sender.  In essence, there is no proof that you even sent the message. This is common practice by organizations and individuals who do not want to be tracked in their answers using email. There is little real dialogue. It is essentially one way. You may get an email response, in which case you will now have an email address for your representative that you can use later for subsequent communications.  

Attached Files

About Dick Conoboy

Citizen Journalist and Editor • Member since Jan 26, 2008

Comments by Readers

M. Lynda Hanscome

Jul 27, 2024

Well said, Dick.  Are these politicians really as clueless as they pretend to be?  You are right:  The ACO’s are outright privitized fraud on Traditional Medicare.  Seniors are supposed to trust their doctors to “do no harm” and yet the doctors sign a secret agreement with the ACO-REACH for profit private entities?  If nothing changes the fraudulent ACO for-profit scheme will doom Medicare and deplete the funds.  If seniors do not wake up and speak up, Medicare will be gone in this generation.  The secret plan from my own background reading is to automatically enroll new seniors in a MA or ACO; Hence, Traditional Medicare will be completely privatized.  It is well on its way now, sadly.

Read More...
To comment, Log In or Register

First Murray. Now Larsen. Half Trillion Dollar Theft From Medicare: Not An Issue.

By Dick ConoboyOn Jul 27, 2024

Heaven forbid our reps should attack the main problem, Medicare Advantage, head on. But no. They must nibble around the edges to give the appearance of doing something.

1 comment, most recent 2 months ago

Moral Injury Links Medicare Advantage Physicians To Combat Veterans

By Dick ConoboyOn Jun 16, 2024

Morally significant double binds force doctors and combat soldiers into identical life and death quandaries, damaging their moral centers. To these two groups we can also add law enforcement officers.

4 comments, most recent 3 months ago

Over A Half Trillion Dollars Stolen From Medicare - Sen. Patty Murray Is OK With That

By Dick ConoboyOn Jun 14, 2024

It is time to stop the “Real Steal” from Medicare.

3 comments, most recent 3 months ago

The Scrap Heap - The Real Message

By David Netboy On Jun 12, 2024

Aggressive citizen involvement carried the day.

5 comments, most recent 3 months ago

All Remaining ABC Scrap Metal Is On Ship

By John ServaisOn Jun 10, 2024

The last of the scrap metal is loaded on the ship and it will be gone from our town.

1 comment, most recent 4 months ago

Memorial Day 2024 - Remembering My Friends

By Dick ConoboyOn May 25, 2024

If not killed-in-action, they are still dying from the effects of their service in Vietnam.

7 comments, most recent 4 months ago

Moving Back from the Brink

By Gene MarxOn Apr 05, 2024

Pacific Northwest organizers join a global campaign to abolish all nukes and push for a city council resolution to start

4 comments, most recent 5 months ago

Medicare (Dis)Advantage - Even Hospitals Don’t Like It.

By Dick ConoboyOn Mar 31, 2024

If the hospitals are smelling a rat, so should Medicare (Dis)Advantage victims (AKA enrollees).

2 comments, most recent 4 months ago

The Insidious Creep of Medicare (Dis)Advantage

By Guest WriterOn Feb 25, 2024

Crappier coverage for us, even more money for insurance companies.

3 comments, most recent 7 months ago

Chutzpah Redefined - Call For Citizen Policing of Medicare Advantage

By Dick ConoboyOn Dec 02, 2023

Biden administration is asking the public to report on bogus advertising claims of Medicare Advantage providers.

7 comments, most recent 10 months ago

ABC Recycling Meets the Public

By Guest WriterOn Nov 28, 2023

Tuesday, Dec, 5, will be the first time ABC Recycling has agreed to answer the public. Don’t miss this meeting. Here are the issues.

6 comments, most recent 10 months ago

Scamming Our Veterans

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 17, 2023

There seems to be no barrier to the depths to which scammers will go to steal money from the most vulnerable or deserving.

Thoughts of a Bellingham Renter

By Guest WriterOn Nov 08, 2023

An insider’s view of rental inspections in Bellingham as experienced by a long-time renter.

5 comments, most recent 11 months ago

Retirees With Federal Employee Health Care - Beware Of Offers To Switch Drug Coverage

By Dick ConoboyOn Nov 04, 2023

Getting a letter that declares, “An exciting new prescription drug benefit for you!” should activate your BS detector.

7 comments, most recent 9 months ago

Signing On To Medicare Advantage?  Don’t!

By Dick ConoboyOn Oct 18, 2023

Or at least, take a moment to learn about the privatization of Medicare, commonly called Medicare [Dis]Advantage.

1 comment, most recent 11 months ago

The Hazards of Metal Shredding near Bellingham: Cancer, Pollution and Fire

By Guest WriterOn Oct 02, 2023

The passage of time alone will not save Bellingham from this dangerous situation. Only strong and persistent action on the part of its citizens will be effective against this menace.

Scrap Metal Pile Includes Many Hazards and Few Benefits

By Guest WriterOn Sep 27, 2023

[Our Guest Writer, Scott Jones, is a Bellingham resident along with his family.  He is President of ...

7 comments, most recent 1 year ago

The Long History of Corporate Fraud and Abuse in Medicare

By Guest WriterOn May 05, 2023

[The following is reprinted from The Retiree Advocate, monthly newsletter of Puget Sound Advocates for Retirement Action (PSARA). &...

1 comment, most recent 1 year ago

Restoring Health of Land and Water—Bellingham Style

By David Netboy On Apr 30, 2023

Toxic waste, scrap recycling, jarring noise, and dubious processes on the waterfront: How did this happen?

10 comments, most recent 1 year ago

City Council Review of Rental Registration and Inspection Ordinance

By Dick ConoboyOn Apr 25, 2023

A review and update of Bellingham’s rental registration and inspection program is long overdue.

10 comments, most recent 1 year ago